Supply Chain Management. The words are a freely exchanged coin of the realm. The promise is considerable: an overarching discipline that incorporates all of operations, finance, customers, suppliers, and even research and development as well as critical aspects of sales and marketing into a single scope that ultimately focuses on maximizing the financial performance of the firm. Yet after over 50 years of evolutionary development, reality has fallen well short of expectations: Cross-functional integration is impeded by corporate organizational structures, culture, and inappropriate performance metrics.
Certain processes and tools, most notably sales and operations planning (S&OP), have been developed to address such shortcomings. Yet these have often failed to live up to their promise as well, often due to inadequate decision support technology. This results in substantial expenditures of time and money with little of substance to show for the effort. So, are SCM and S&OP misguided and overrated? Or, is it a matter of not having the right analytics tools and implementation processes?
Those are questions we will explore in depth over the following pages. Before that, let’s be clear at the outset what this article is not about. First, it is not a primer on either SCM or S&OP. That territory has already been mapped by others. Rather, we assume that the reader has a working knowledge of both subjects. It is also not a comprehensive presentation of analytics—advanced or otherwise.
![]() |
This complete article is available to subscribers
only. Click on Log In Now at the top of this article for full access. Or, Start your PLUS+ subscription for instant access. |
SC
MR
![]() |
Download Article PDF |
Supply Chain Management. The words are a freely exchanged coin of the realm. The promise is considerable: an overarching discipline that incorporates all of operations, finance, customers, suppliers, and even research and development as well as critical aspects of sales and marketing into a single scope that ultimately focuses on maximizing the financial performance of the firm. Yet after over 50 years of evolutionary development, reality has fallen well short of expectations: Cross-functional integration is impeded by corporate organizational structures, culture, and inappropriate performance metrics.
Certain processes and tools, most notably sales and operations planning (S&OP), have been developed to address such shortcomings. Yet these have often failed to live up to their promise as well, often due to inadequate decision support technology. This results in substantial expenditures of time and money with little of substance to show for the effort. So, are SCM and S&OP misguided and overrated? Or, is it a matter of not having the right analytics tools and implementation processes?
Those are questions we will explore in depth over the following pages. Before that, let’s be clear at the outset what this article is not about. First, it is not a primer on either SCM or S&OP. That territory has already been mapped by others. Rather, we assume that the reader has a working knowledge of both subjects. It is also not a comprehensive presentation of analytics—advanced or otherwise.
![]() |
SUBSCRIBERS: Click here to download PDF of the full article. |
SC
MR

Latest Supply Chain News
- Developing supply chain talent for new product development
- Finance as a transformation catalyst: A How-To guide for supply chain finance leaders
- Procurement’s Moneyball Moment: Connecting Strategy, Sourcing, and Supply Chain Reality
- AI won’t fix a broken supply chain foundation
- How I vibe-coded an S&OP app in 30 hours
- More News
Latest Resources

Explore
Topics
Latest Supply Chain News
- Developing supply chain talent for new product development
- Finance as a transformation catalyst: A How-To guide for supply chain finance leaders
- Procurement’s Moneyball Moment: Connecting Strategy, Sourcing, and Supply Chain Reality
- AI won’t fix a broken supply chain foundation
- How I vibe-coded an S&OP app in 30 hours
- The AI regulation gap: Risk, cost, and competitive advantage
- More latest news
Latest Resources

Subscribe

Supply Chain Management Review delivers the best industry content.

Editors’ Picks

