Login



For PLUS+ subscription assistance, contact customer service.

Not a PLUS+ Subscriber?

Become a PLUS+ Subscriber today and you'll get access to all Supply Chain Management Review premium content including:

  • Full Web Access
  • 7 Magazine Issues per Year
  • Companion Digital Editions
  • Digital Edition Archives
  • Bonus Email Newsletters

Subscribe Today!

Premium access to exclusive online content, companion digital editions, magazine issues and email newsletters.

Subscribe Now.


Become a PLUS+ subscriber and you'll get access to all Supply Chain Management Review premium content including:

  • Full Web Access. All feature articles, bonus reports and industry research through scmr.com.

  • 7 Magazine Issues per year of Supply Chain Management Review magazine.

  • Companion Digital Editions. Searchable replicas of each magazine issue. Read them in any web browser. Delivered by email faster than printed issues.

  • Digital Editions Archives. Every article, every chart and every table as it appeared in the magazine for all archive issues back to 2009.

  • Bonus email newsletters. Add convenient weekly and monthly email newsletters to your subscription to keep your finger on the pulse of the industry.

PLUS+ subscriptions start as low as $109/year*. Begin yours now.
That's less than $0.36 per day for access to information that you can use year-round to better manage your entire global supply chain.

For assistance with your PLUS+ subscription, contact customer service.

* Prices higher for subscriptions outside the USA.

You have been logged out of PLUS+


For PLUS+ subscription assistance, contact customer service.

Need to access our premium PLUS+ Content?
Upgrade your subscription now.


Our records show that you are currently receiving a free subscription to Supply Chain Management Review magazine, or your subscription has expired. To access our premium content, you need to upgrade your subscription to our PLUS+ status.

To upgrade your subscription account, please contact customer service at:

Email: [email protected] Phone: 1-800-598-6067 (1-508-663-1500 x294 outside USA)

Become a PLUS+ subscriber and you'll get access to all Supply Chain Management Review premium content including:

  • Full Web Access. All feature articles, bonus reports and industry research through scmr.com.

  • 7 Magazine Issues per year of Supply Chain Management Review magazine.

  • Companion Digital Editions. Searchable replicas of each magazine issue. Read them in any web browser. Delivered by email faster than printed issues.

  • Digital Editions Archives. Every article, every chart and every table as it appeared in the magazine for all archive issues back to 2010.

  • Bonus email newsletters. Add convenient weekly and monthly email newsletters to your subscription to keep your finger on the pulse of the industry.

PLUS+ subscriptions start as low as $129/year*. Start yours now.
That's less than $0.36 per day for access to information that you can use year-round to better manage your entire global supply chain.

This content is available for PLUS+ subscribers.


Already a PLUS+ subscriber?


To begin or upgrade your subscription, Become a PLUS+ subscriber now.

For assistance with your PLUS+ subscription, contact customer service.

Sorry, but your login to PLUS+ has failed.


Please recheck your login information and resubmit below.



For PLUS+ subscription assistance, contact customer service.

Which Carriers Should You Should Use?

Our findings suggest that carriers cater to varying market needs.

By ·
By ·

Editor’s Note: Every year, 40 or so students in the MIT Center for Transportation & Logistics’ (MIT CTL) Master of Supply Chain Management (SCM) program complete one-year thesis research projects.  The students are early-career business professionals from multiple countries with 2 to 10 years of experience in the industry.  Most of the research projects are chosen, sponsored by, and carried out in collaboration with multinational corporations.  Joint teams that include MIT SCM students and MIT CTL faculty work on the real-world problems.  In this series, we summarize a selection of the latest SCM research. 

Trucking companies are rated on a general scorecard, which allows them to benchmark, and gives shippers some guidance on performance levels when developing their routing guides.

But what if current scorecards are too general to give shippers the information they need to create a portfolio of high-performance carriers with different market strategies?

In our research on the attributes of high-performing carriers, we analyzed the impact of individual and groups of attributes on service performance. We used a three-year dataset of both tender level and stop level data from TMC, a subsidiary of C. H. Robinson.

One of the insights from the research is that there were clear distinctions in marketplace roles and subsequent strategies between carriers, which had direct implications for their general service performance.

Which entities are performing?

Binary logistic regression and hierarchical clustering were used to identify the individual and groups of freight attributes that impacted performance success in terms of on time delivery, on time pick up, and first tender acceptance rate. 

Three main performance groups of carriers were identified and their subsequent underlying attributes and strategies analyzed.  This research confirmed industry belief that differing strategies and freight profile roles result in different performance levels; specifically, that more focused carriers tend to provide better service than unfocused carriers.

The research also showed that some groups of attributes work together to improve freight performance.  These include longer lead times, consistency of load volume, geographic and lane focus, younger price ages, and certain mixes of types of both asset and non-asset carriers within a shipper’s portfolio.  An analysis of shippers’ portfolios of the carriers employing different strategies showed that diversified portfolios with a higher proportion of more focused carriers have stronger performance. 

The research provides some guidance for shippers in building their routing guides. For example:

1. Identify more focused carriers on the lanes you need to use. This advice stems from the focus-based performance findings derived from asset and non-asset clustering analyses.

2. When broader coverage is needed, use the larger carriers that have familiarity on the lanes you will be using. These carriers fill the “regional leader” role on those lanes.

Why does strategy matter?

This research offers a strategic review of groups of freight attributes that contribute to performance outcome.  Within this review, carriers were shown to have different underlying roles within shippers’ portfolios, which may suggest the need for different ways to measure their performance. Our findings suggest that carriers cater to varying market needs. The differences in strategy within the clustering analyses for both asset and non-asset carriers, implies that the uniform scorecards used to evaluate shipper performance may not be the most appropriate way to rate carriers.

There is a research opportunity in developing more strategy-specific key performance indicators (KPIs) and corresponding scorecards, to give shippers a better understanding of the performance of carriers relative to their specific market needs.

The SCM thesis Understanding Carrier Strategy and Performance was authored by Caroline Bleggi and Frederick (Qian) Zhou, and supervised by Dr. Chris Caplice, Executive Director, MIT Center for Transportation & Logistics. The research partner was C. H. Robinson. For more information on the research please contact Chris Caplice at: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)


About the Author

Patrick Burnson, Executive Editor
Patrick Burnson is executive editor for Logistics Management and Supply Chain Management Review magazines and web sites. Patrick is a widely-published writer and editor who has spent most of his career covering international trade, global logistics, and supply chain management. He lives and works in San Francisco, providing readers with a Pacific Rim perspective on industry trends and forecasts. You can reach him directly at [email protected]

Subscribe to Supply Chain Management Review Magazine!

Subscribe today. Don't Miss Out!
Get in-depth coverage from industry experts with proven techniques for cutting supply chain costs and case studies in supply chain best practices.
Start Your Subscription Today!

Latest Whitepaper
Supplier Relationship Micro Management
Optimizing Across Six Guiding Principles
Download Today!
From the July-August 2017
Subscribe to Our Email Newsletter
Sign up today to receive our FREE, weekly email newsletter!


Latest Webcast
Fueling S&OP with Technology
Successful Sales & Operations Planning must be powered by process-enabling technology that can move at the pace of today’s global business environment. Join this webinar to learn the key S&OP technologies necessary to drive the best business value at your company.
Register Today!
EDITORS' PICKS
Kuebix/SimpliShip Partnership May Create New Opportunities for Global Supply Chain Managers
With Kuebix TMS, supply chain managers may be enabled to enhance rating, booking and managing of...
Supplier Audits Remain Essential, Says AsiaInspection
The Hong Kong-based consultancy has just released its 2017 Q3 Barometer, a quarterly synopsis on...

U.S. Supply Chain Infrastructure “Healthy,” Says Fitch Ratings
Fitch views near-term U.S. economic trends favorably with modest 2.1% GDP growth this year even amid...
Addressing Risk In Big Data is Key For Supply Chain Management
Truckstop.com is charged with giving supply chain information in real-time so that they can mitigate...